One of the most popular investments in India is mutual funds. They enable investors to invest in a professionally managed fund which can be stocks, bonds or any other securities. Investors also enjoy the services of skilled fund managers instead of investing on their own. In the process of investing in mutual funds, one of the most important decisions the investors must make is to understand the difference between active and passive mutual funds.
Both types are different, and the knowledge of the difference can assist investors in better decision-making based on their financial objectives and risk preferences.
What are Active Mutual Funds?
Active mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers who strive to produce returns that are above the market standards like the Nifty 50, or the BSE Sensex.
Active funds involve a fund manager who actively picks stocks and decides how the portfolio should be managed. The portfolio is analyzed and revised on a regular basis depending on the market trends, economic trends and the performance of the company. The Long-term goal of an active mutual fund is to generate returns that exceed overall market performance.
Key Features of Active Funds:
- Professionally managed and based on research.
- Target to generate returns that are higher than the benchmark (alpha).
- Dynamic portfolio management approach.
- Increased expense ratio associated with research and trading.
Active funds suit investors who are ready to take a risk in exchange for the possible high returns.
What are Passive Mutual Funds?
Passive mutual funds aim to track the performance of a market index instead of outperforming it. These are funds that track a given index such as the NIFTY 50 or Sensex and invest in the same stocks in the same proportions as the index. Management expenses are minimal through low buying and selling.
Key Features of Passive Funds:
- Track a particular market index.
- No active stock selection.
- Lower expense ratio.
- The returns are very close to the benchmark.
Passive funds are ideal in a situation where an investor is seeking long-term, consistent returns with regard to the market at a low cost.
Difference Between Active and Passive Mutual Funds in India
The major difference between active and passive mutual funds is given below:
| Basis of Difference | Active Mutual Funds | Passive Mutual Funds |
| Objective | Outperform the market benchmark | Match the market benchmark |
| Management Style | Actively managed by fund managers | Automatically tracks an index |
| Expense Ratio | Higher | Lower |
| Risk Level | Slightly higher (depends on manager decisions) | Market risk only |
| Return Potential | Can outperform (not guaranteed) | Equal to market returns |
| Transparency | Portfolio may change frequently | Highly transparent |
Performance Comparison Between Active and Passive Mutual Funds
Active mutual funds have the potential to provide better returns when the market conditions are good. Nevertheless, not all of the active funds will always outperform their indices.
Passive mutual funds may not provide the additional returns, but they provide a consistent performance in line with general market expansion.
Passive investing has gained popularity in India over the last few years as a result of:
- Growing cost awareness.
- Growing preference for index-based investing.
- Emphasis long-term wealth creation.
Advantages of Active Mutual Funds
Main advantages of active mutual funds are:
- The possibility of increased returns.
- Adaptability to market fluctuations.
- Research-based professional decision-making.
- Appropriate to dynamic market conditions.
Limitations:
- Higher expense ratio.
- It all depends on the expertise of the fund manager when it comes to performance.
- Better performance is not guaranteed.
Advantages of Passive Mutual Funds:
- Low cost
- Simple and clear structure.
- Suitable for long-term investor.
- Removes fund manager selection risk.
Limitations:
- Cannot exceed the index
- Lack of flexibility during market downturns.
Active or Passive Mutual Funds: Which One Should Investors Choose?
There is no universal answer. The choice depends on the investor’s financial goals and risk profile.
Choose Active Mutual Funds if:
- You are comfortable with moderate risk.
- You want the opportunity of greater returns.
- You believe in professional portfolio management.
Use Passive Mutual Funds when:
- You favour low-cost investing.
- You want predictable, market-linked returns.
- You are making long-term investments such as retirement.
Most financial advisors recommend a combination of both approaches to have a balanced portfolio diversification.
Active and Passive Mutual Funds in India: The Current Trend
Passive investment in India has experienced massive growth in recent years. Index funds and ETFs are becoming popular due to:
- Awareness of expense ratios.
- The rise of SIP culture.
- The emphasis on long-term wealth generation.
Nonetheless, active funds continue to manage a bigger portion of the Indian mutual fund assets under management since most investors prefer the benefits of professional management.
Conclusion
The primary variations between the active and passive mutual funds are related to their style of management, cost structure, and management of returns. Active funds attempt to outperform the market by making decisions with professionalism, yet they are more expensive. Passive funds, on the other hand, seek to track market performance at a reduced cost, which is subject to regular growth over time. The ideal option will be based on the financial goals, risk aversion, and investment horizon. A blend of both approaches is potentially the most effective for many investors.
Other Mutual Fund related Blogs
| What is Mutual Fund | Regular vs Direct Mutual Funds |
| Mutual Funds vs. Equity | Types of Mutual Fund Schemes |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the key difference between Passive and Active Mutual Funds?
The primary difference between active and passive mutual funds lies in the manner of management. Active funds are operated by professionals who seek to beat a set index such as the NIFTY 50 or BSE Sensex. Passive funds only follow an index and strive to be in line with its performance.
Is it better to invest in an Active or Passive Mutual Fund?
None of them is always better. Active funds tend to earn more returns however at a greater cost and risk. Passive funds are inexpensive and offer predictable returns that are linked to the market. The more suitable one is based on your risk orientation, financial objectives and investment horizon.
Do Passive Mutual Funds outperform Active Funds?
Passive funds usually have only market risk since they track an index. Active funds can have more risk depending on the capacity of the fund manager. But they both are vulnerable to market changes.
Why are the expense ratios of Active Mutual Funds higher?
Active funds are characterised by research, analysis, constant buying and selling of securities and professional fund management. These operations raise the operational costs making the expense ratio high as compared to passive funds.
Are Passive Mutual Funds equivalent to Index Funds?
Yes. A passive mutual fund is referred to as an index fund. They imitate the activity of a particular market index and have the same asset allocation as the index they follow.
Learn More About Mutual Funds