An investor in India has two options when it comes to investing in silver: Silver ETFs or the purchase of physical silver in the form of coins or bars. Although both options enable you to enjoy the fluctuations in the price of silver, they are differentiated by the ease with which they are bought, the price at which they are bought, how readily they can be sold, and with what aim. Being aware of Silver ETF vs Physical Silver makes it easier to decide which alternative fits your investment objectives and preferences.
What are Silver ETFs?
Silver ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) are market-linked instruments that are pegged to the price of silver. They allow investors silver investments without having to buy or store silver itself. When the market is open, silver ETFs can be bought and sold just like regular stocks on stock exchanges like the NSE and BSE.
What is Physical Silver?
Physical silver is silver that is held in physical form, such as silver coins, bars, biscuits, or jewelry. Investors buy physical silver from jewellers, banks, or authorized dealers and hold it as a tangible asset.
Difference between Silver ETFs and Physical Silver
Indian buyers who want to buy silver usually have to choose between Silver ETFs or Physical silver. Both let you bet on the price of silver, but they are not the same in terms of cost, ease of use, liquidity, or how well they spend your money.
| Criteria | Silver ETFs | Physical Silver |
| Form | Silver ETFs are paper/digital investments traded on stock exchanges. | It is held in tangible form such as coins, bars, or jewellery. |
| Storage | Does not require storage or security arrangements. | Physical silver needs safe storage and may involve locker or insurance costs. |
| Liquidity | Offer high liquidity with real-time buying and selling on NSE and BSE. | It may take time to sell and often attract price discounts. |
| Cost | ETFs charge an expense ratio and brokerage charges, but no GST is applicable on ETF purchase. | It includes making charges, GST, and storage expenses. |
| Purity Risk | Silver ETFs eliminate purity concerns as they are backed by standardized high-purity silver. | Purity depends on the seller. |
| Price Transparency | Prices closely track market rates. | Prices may be different because of dealer fees. |
Which One is Right for You?
The choice between Silver ETFs and Physical silver will be determined by your investment plans and expectations of your investment in silver.
Choose Silver ETFs if you:
- Want to invest by opening a Demat account.
- Favor high liquidity and the ability to buy or sell during market hours.
- Looking for short to medium-term gains.
- Desire access to silver without having to store or be secured.
- Intend to invest in small/frequency amounts
Choose Physical Silver if you:
- Appreciate the real possession of silver coins or bars.
- Investment to protect wealth in the long-run.
- Need a hedge in case of economic or market risk.
- Prefer a non-counterparty risk investment.
Best of Both Worlds:
A large number of investors choose a moderate course.
- Use Silver ETFs to have liquidity and to diversify the portfolio.
- Physically hold silver for long-term security and stability.
Key Takeaway
Silver ETFs and physical silver possess their respective pros and cons. Silver ETFs can be considered more convenient, liquid, transparent, and cost effective to the investor who wants convenience, whereas the traditional physical silver is more appreciated by the investors who prefer to have tangible possession and use over time.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Which is safer: Silver ETF or physical silver?
In different ways, both are safe. Silver ETFs get rid of the risks of storage and purity, while physical silver doesn’t depend on a market platform but needs to be stored safely.
How is investing in a Silver ETF different from buying physical silver?
When you invest in a Silver ETF, you buy units electronically through a Demat and trading account. Physical silver involves purchasing coins, bars or jewellery, which requires storage and may include making charges or purity concerns.
Are Silver ETFs more tax-efficient than Physical Silver in India?
Silver ETFs are generally taxed as non-equity mutual funds in India, where capital gains tax depends on the holding period. Physical silver is taxed as a capital asset, and gains are subject to applicable capital gains tax as per prevailing income tax rules.
Do Silver ETFs track the actual price of Silver?
Yes, Silver ETFs aim to closely track domestic silver prices, subject to minor tracking errors and expense ratios. The performance depends on underlying silver prices and fund management efficiency.
Is liquidity better in Silver ETFs compared to Physical silver?
Silver ETFs are traded on stock exchanges, offering high liquidity during market hours. Physical silver may take time to sell and could involve price negotiations or deductions.
Who should consider buying Physical Silver instead of a Silver ETF?
Investors who prefer tangible assets for gifting, traditional purposes or long-term physical holding may opt for physical silver. It may also suit those who do not have access to a Demat account.
Which option is better for long-term investment: Silver ETF or Physical Silver?
For long-term financial investment and portfolio diversification, Silver ETFs are generally more convenient and cost-efficient. Physical silver may be better suited for personal use or cultural preferences rather than pure investment purposes.
Which is better during Inflation: Silver ETF or Physical Silver?
Silver prices go up during inflation, which is good for both, but Silver ETFs offer easy entry and exit with transparent pricing.
Learn More About Investment